Monday, November 19, 2007

SAT Vocabulary 1.9 How much will a great SAT score help?

For the most selective colleges, we do have a little bit of data about SAT score distribution which shows how chances of acceptance rise with SAT scores.

On the one hand, this is just a way of stating the obvious. On the other hand, many people think that once you hit the low- to mid-range SAT score for your target school, your score no longer matters, and the data suggests that this belief is probably not true.

Here's a chart from one study ("A Revealed Preference Ranking of U.S. Colleges and Universities," conducted by Avery, Glickman, Hoxby, and Metrick, on page 7):



This survey suggests that acceptance at the most competitive schools increases dramatically--in fact, becomes several times more likely--as SAT scores rise from the 88th percentile to the 99th. (The authors of the study explain the strange dip in the Princeton graph by suggesting that Princeton deliberately rejects some students who are likely to be accepted to Harvard: they suggest that, at some schools, "A student's probability of admission will first rise in his or her merit and then fall as his or her merit moves into the range in which the strategic college faces stiff competition [p. 7].")

This trend is even more apparent in the excellent book The Early Admissions Game, which has been made partially available through Google Books. These authors have charted admissions as a factor of SAT scores at several top universities, including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Brown, Stanford, and MIT, and you can find the charts online. If you like, you can take a look at the bar graphs on page 153-55. (Once you follow this link, you'll have to click on the "Search Books" button and then click on the first link in the search results to get to the graphs. For some reason I can't figure out how to link directly to the pages. If you know how, please leave a comment about it and I'll fix the link.)

The findings of Avery et al. are duplicated here: for instance, you are two to three times as likely to be accepted at Yale if you have an SAT score near the top of their range (1550-1600 CR/M combined) than if you have a score toward the low end of average (1410/1450 CR/M combined).

Of course, correlation is not causality. In other words, even if kids with mad high scores get in to Yale a lot, it may not be their scores getting them in. Students with perfect SATs are likely to have a number of other things going for them, like high grades, major academic awards, and strong recommendations; so who knows exactly what these figures mean? Probably they mean a little, but it may be only a very little.

So what should you do? Should you kill yourself to move from a 710-790 (gack)? Should you ignore your friends who tell you that a 2280 is a fantastic score?

Probably not. In my opinion, it all comes down to the number one rule of college applications: Maximize your strengths.

This rule is so important that one day I'll write a separate post, maybe a separate series of posts, on what it means.

When you prepare for the college process--and, really, as you go through life--your primary goal should not be to minimize your weaknesses, but rather to maximize your strengths. That's your own personal strengths, bucko. The strengths of your friends, rivals, neighbors, and mother's friends' children are irrelevant here.

If standardized tests are a personal specialty of yours, and you hit a 700/700/700 on your first practice test, you might want to take a few more practice exams before you sit down to a real test in a real testing center. After all, you might have a shot at that perfect or near-perfect score, and it would certainly be an ace in the hole for you.

Those of you grinding your teeth in jealousy at the idea of anyone being a naturally gifted test-taker: trust me, these kids often have a slew of weaknesses, such as disappointing grades. (I know. I was one of them.) Again, this is about maximizing your strengths, not comparing yourself to other people.

At the same time, SAT preparations definitely follow the law of diminishing returns. If you start off with a CR score in the low 600s, you may have a terrible time trying to pull it up to the 99th percentile. (I've seen a few exceptions, where students who were already powerful readers were able to skyrocket up through practice and tactics, but those kids are rare). You want to maximize your own strengths, not fit some cookie-cutter image. Plenty of kids get in to every school in the country--every single school, including the most selective--with a section or two solidly in the 600s. If standardized tests are not your particular strength, you may want to get your scores into the ballpark through steady practice and try to set yourself apart another way. You are much more likely to be successful, and you will be much happier doing it.

So, to sum up:

a) It's wise to make every attempt to raise your CR score to the average range of your target schools, and
b) If test-taking is one of your natural strengths, you might not want to blow off the idea of preparing. Invest a few hours and who knows? You might get an extraordinary score.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home